See below for details about the protest by PETA at opening day of the Christmas Spectacular, featuring a camel trapped in a snowglobe chained to the floor.
We asked of PETA about the suggested puppet design and live animal phase out: What would be the requested time frame for the phase-out? Would it be by next year? I am assuming it can’t be this year. This is the company you are now shareholders in? Are there board meetings that your org attends for that?
A: “PETA is urging Radio City to immediately commit to not using animals in its Christmas Spectacular production. There is still time to decide not to use animals in this year’s show. If Radio City agrees to stop forcing distressed animals to take the stage and be stored backstage like props for months on end, PETA will fund a beautiful puppet from a world-class puppet maker for the Christmas Spectacular. Radio City could participate in the creation to whatever degree they choose, as long as they spare animals from enduring the stress of future shows.
PETA purchased stock in Madison Square Garden Entertainment Corp.—Radio City’s parent company—earlier this year, and will be able to attend the company’s annual meetings to convince directors and shareholders to stop using live animals in the nativity scene in the Christmas Spectacular. The company’s annual meeting is typically in December, and PETA will bring this issue to the meeting.”
A: Yes, PETA has reached out privately to the archbishop to ask for his help for the animals.
Q: Has anyone ever managed to take video of the animals showing their distress or condition? Maybe during the blessing, during the performance, or (less likely unless a worker shared it) backstage?
A: Here is a photo a whistleblower sent to PETA of a camel tied up backstage at Radio City Music Hall. PETA has also released photos showing how the camels are typically kept in small enclosures at the exhibitor’s facility when they aren’t at Radio City. FYI that it is prohibited to record during the shows.
The Rockettes may soon have some competition for the spotlight: a life-size, beautifully crafted camel puppet, courtesy of PETA. Ahead of this year’s Christmas Spectacular, PETA this morning sent a letter to the show’s director and choreographer, Julie Branam, offering to fund the custom creation if Radio City Music Hall retires the live camels, sheep, and donkeys from its Nativity scene. The switch would let Radio City create Christmas magic through imaginative stagecraft rather than subjecting animals to disorienting lights and loud music—and, as PETA points out, Broadway’s The Lion King has already proved that sophisticated puppetry can bring animals to life and captivate audiences.
“Radio City must stop dragging stressed camels, sheep, and donkeys across the stage and leave this cruel, archaic practice in the past, where it belongs,” says PETA President Tracy Reiman. “PETA stands ready to fund a life-size camel puppet that can deliver a showstopping Nativity scene without treating living, feeling animals like props.”
When they’re not being forced to perform, animals used in the Christmas Spectacular are confined backstage, with some reportedly kept in the basement, during the show’s months-long run every winter. Nearly 40,000 PETA supporters have called on Chase, Lexus, and Verizon to not sponsor the show until it stops using live animals. PETA is also taking its “Camels Aren’t Props” message across New York City, with a giant camel towering over Times Square and additional displays appearing on a massive wallscape and kiosks.
Concept for the life-size camel puppet PETA is offering to fund for the Christmas Spectacular. Credit: PETA
PETA’s letter to Branam follows.
October 14, 2026
Julie Branam
Director and Choreographer
Christmas Spectacular
Dear Ms. Branam:
For generations, the Christmas Spectacular has captivated audiences, but one part of the production remains stuck in the past: the continued use of camels, sheep, and donkeys. I’m writing on behalf of PETA with a solution—if Radio City Music Hall commits to ending the use of live animals in the show, PETA will pay for the creation of a stunning, world-class camel puppet to take their place. Here’s what we have in mind for your truly spectacular puppet:
Imagine breathtaking puppetry that’s lifelike, awe-inspiring, and leaves audiences speechless. Radio City could embrace innovation befitting of its iconic stage, saving real animals from being subjected to bright lights, loud music, and unfamiliar environments night after night. Some of New York’s most successful productions creatively work animals into their shows using innovative alternatives, and just this year, The Royal Ballet and Opera banned live animals from their productions and opted for a beautifully crafted prop instead.
I look forward to hearing from you about this exciting option that would bring special Christmas magic to Radio City Music Hall.
Sincerely,
Tracy Reiman
President
Sad ‘Camel’ Trapped in Snow Globe to Protest Radio City Animal Acts on Opening Day
As the Christmas Spectacular kicks off its holiday run on Wednesday, PETA will give Radio City Music Hall a shake-up with a sad, chained “camel” trapped inside a giant inflatable snow globe. PETA supporters will rally alongside the display to call attention to the camels, sheep, and donkeys suffering in the show, holding signs reading “Take Cruelty Out of Christmas. Drop Animal Acts!”
“The camels, sheep, and donkeys forced to perform in Christmas Spectacular don’t get to go home when the curtain falls—they remain confined and isolated backstage throughout the show’s months-long run,” says PETA President Tracy Reiman. “PETA is calling on Radio City to use willing human performers and imaginative puppets and give animals the peace they deserve this Christmas.”
Camels are social animals who express their feelings with groans, moans, and roars; donkeys can recognize the faces of animals they haven’t seen for years; and sheep’s heart rates increase when they can’t find their family or are approached by strangers. Animals used in live Nativities face a constant barrage of activity and unwanted touches and are often tethered and made to stand on hard surfaces for hours. Their handlers commonly threaten and intimidate them—many use abusive tools to make them obey commands out of fear of physical punishment.
Banner Image: Camel puppet. Image Credit – PETA