Six of NYC’s 10 Sharpest Renter-Occupied Share Gains Were in Staten Island
Editor’s note: This trend follows on a previous study regarding homeownership proportions in Staten Island, where it directly contrasts with the more urban boroughs.
-
Charleston and Midland Beach posted the second and third largest gains in renter-occupied share citywide, up 20 and 13 percentage points, to 39% and 29%, respectively
-
Manor Heights posted one of the city’s 10 biggest owner-occupied share gains, up 11 ppt to 67%
-
Manhattan’s Civic Center saw its share of owner-occupied homes rise 18 ppt to 40%, the largest gain citywide, after the number of renter-occupied homes were almost halved over the last decade
A Decade of Homeownership Trends Across NYC Neighborhoods: Where Owners Gained Ground & Where Renters Took Over
Shifts in homeownership trends led Manhattan to record the highest increase in the share of owner-occupied homes, while Staten Island stood out as the only NYC borough where renters gained ground over the past decade.
Key Takeaways:
- In the last decade, NYC’s owner-occupied homes grew at a slightly faster rate than rentals, nudging the owner-occupied share up to 33% of the city’s stock
- Manhattan’s owner-occupied share rose to 25% after an increase of 2.5 percentage points (ppt), marking the largest gain of any borough
- Brooklyn’s owner-renter occupied split held steady at 30/70 even as the borough added some 85,000 new occupied housing units in the last decade
- The Bronx and Manhattan dominated the top 10 neighborhoods with the sharpest gains in the share of owner-occupied homes, led by Civic Center’s 18-ppt increase
- Staten Island and Queens claimed nine of the top 10 spots for gains in renter-occupied share, led by Stapleton with a rise of 22 ppt
Most NYC neighborhoods comprise a mix of owner- and renter-occupied homes, with that balance always evolving according to new developments or broader socio-economic conditions and homeownership trends. So, to see how that mix changed throughout the last decade and which locations saw the largest shifts, we analyzed the share of owner- and renter-occupied housing units across NYC’s five boroughs and 282 neighborhoods using the latest available Census data (2024) vs. 10 years prior.
Homeownership Trends Across NYC Boroughs
Manhattan Led Shift Toward Ownership, Staten Island Moved Toward Renters
In 2024, homeowners occupied nearly two-thirds (65%) of homes across the U.S. and 54% in the state of New York. However, zooming in further on NYC, only 33% of housing units were owner-occupied, with the five boroughs showing different and, sometimes, diverging patterns.
Between 2014 and 2024, the number of owner-occupied homes in New York City grew 11%, outpacing the 6% growth in renter-occupied homes. Because owners start from a much smaller base, however, the citywide split changed only modestly: The owner-occupied share edged up from 32% to 33%, the equivalent of one percentage point, in line with the national increase (64% to 65%). In absolute terms, however, more rental units were added, with a net increase of 133,904 renter-occupied homes versus 104,253 owner-occupied ones.
Manhattan saw the most dramatic shift toward homeownership citywide — a notable movement for a borough long defined by renting. Specifically, the share of owner-occupied homes rose from less than 23% to 25%, or the equivalent of 2.5 ppt and the largest increase of any borough. The gain came almost entirely from owners: Manhattan added roughly 26,600 owner-occupied housing units during the decade and just 6,600 rental units between 2014 and 2024.
Moreover, the 2010s saw Manhattan add the highest number of new condos of any borough with more than 22,300 entering the borough’s stock. Even within a borough that remains overwhelmingly renter-occupied, the share of owner-occupied homes rose significantly in certain neighborhoods. In fact, Manhattan claimed four of the city’s 10 neighborhoods with the largest increases in the share of owner-occupied homes, all of which climbed more than 10 ppt.
By contrast, Staten Island homeownership trends diverged, making it the only borough where the share of owner-occupied homes declined. But, the slight downtick from 69% to 68% owner-occupied units was not a consequence of a decreasing number of owner-occupied homes. Rather, it came as the result of a limited increase in the borough’s overall occupied units (less than 5,700 new units), almost two-thirds of which (roughly 3,500 units) were rentals. Even so, Staten Island still leads NYC by a wide margin and, at 68% owner-occupied homes, it stayed above the national rate of 65%.
Meanwhile, the Bronx remained the city’s most renter-heavy borough with four out of five homes occupied by renters. Yet, the number of owner-occupied homes grew at a faster rate in the Bronx than in any other borough — up 17% since 2014. However, that rate comes from a small base: The gain amounts to about 15,000 homes (the second-smallest after Staten Island). That said, the shift was concentrated enough to place five Bronx neighborhoods among the 10 that tilted strongest toward ownership in the last decade.
Next, Queens added 35,400 owner-occupied homes between 2014 and 2024 — more than any other borough — raising the share of owner-occupied homes to 45% of the borough’s stock of occupied units. Neighborhoods like Kew Gardens and Bay Terrace showed how that increase in owner-occupied homes can play out, but Queens also stood out with a handful of neighborhoods like Ramblersville, where ownership retreated, tilting toward a renter-occupied profile.
At the same time, Brooklyn added roughly 84,600 housing units between 2014 and 2024, growing more than any other borough in absolute terms, although its share of owner-occupied homes didn’t move at all. That’s because it stayed at 30% in both 2014 and 2024 as owners and renters expanded at a pace that kept that balance intact, suggesting that the expectations of Brooklyn buyers and renters are met by the market.
Additionally, while the borough overall saw owner and renter gains cancel each other out, some Brooklyn neighborhoods still recorded sharp increases in owner-occupied or renter-occupied homes. For example, Cobble Hill, Vinegar Hill, DUMBO, and Greenwood Heights all saw their share of owner-occupied homes rise by more than 7% with Vinegar Hill and DUMBO reaching almost full owner-occupied and renter-occupied balance.
Conversely, Fiske Terrace and Manhattan Beach saw the share of renter-occupied homes increase by more than 7%. After these decade-long changes, Manhattan Beach was split almost evenly between owners and renters, whereas, in Fiske Terrace, more than two-thirds of occupied homes were rented.
Top 10 Neighborhoods Where Owners Gained Ground
Where Owners Gained the Most Ground: The Bronx Claimed Half of NYC’s Top-10 Neighborhoods
Reinforcing borough-level trends, the Bronx — the city’s most renter-heavy borough — placed five neighborhoods among the 10 with the highest increases in the share of owner-occupied homes. Manhattan followed with four and Staten Island claimed one as the only borough where the owner-occupied share declined overall. Notably, a common thread runs through most of these neighborhoods: Not only has the number of owner-occupied homes increased, but the number of rentals has also dropped.
Manhattan’s Civic Center (#1) topped the citywide ranking with its owner-occupied share up 18 ppt to 40%. However, given Civic Center’s relatively low number of occupied units, the jump reflects a sharp drop in renters, rather than a surge in owners — although the neighborhood did gain some 100 owner-occupied homes. Specifically, renter-occupied homes were almost halved between 2014 and 2024, which also constricted the overall stock of occupied units.
At #3, Koreatown was another Manhattan neighborhood with a sharp increase (15.5 ppt) in the share of owner-occupied homes, but an overall small number of occupied units (less than 1,000 units). That brought the neighborhood’s share of owner-occupied homes to 30% in 2024.
For comparison, the more substantial Manhattan gains in owner-occupied shares came in condo-heavy Battery Park City (#7) and Chinatown (#9). With an increase of 11 ppt, Battery Park City showed how rentals turning into condos can contribute to shifts in a neighborhood’s ownership landscape. So, despite the number of residential units remaining virtually unchanged during the last decade, the neighborhood’s owner-occupied share climbed from 19% to 30% as apartment towers like 22 River Terrace converted to condos.
Meanwhile, the number of owner-occupied homes in Chinatown more than doubled since 2014, lifting their share of the neighborhood’s total occupied units by 10 ppt. This brought Chinatown to 19% owner-occupied, which is still the lowest among the top 10 neighborhoods in the ranking, but a significant expansion nonetheless.
Moving into the Bronx, City Island (#2) recorded the second-largest jump in the city, up 17 ppt, going from a slight majority of owner-occupied homes (57%) to a dominant one (74%) in the course of a decade. The shift here came from both a decline in renter-occupied homes and a wave of new owners. Both movements (though otherwise subdued in absolute numbers) have had a significant influence on a neighborhood with a limited number of occupied units.
Coming in at #4 in the ranking, Baychester grew by 12 ppt to a 62% share of owner-occupied homes. By contrast, in 2014, Baychester’s stock of occupied units was equally split between owner- and renter-occupied homes. In Kingsbridge (#5), the share of owner-occupied homes also rose 12 ppt to 24%. This came as the neighborhood’s small pool of owner-occupied homes doubled, whereas the number of renter-occupied homes dropped by roughly 10%.
Also underscoring the Bronx’s presence in this ranking were North Riverdale at #6 and Riverdale at #10, two northwest Bronx neighborhoods dominated by co-ops. In North Riverdale, the share of owner-occupied homes rose 11 ppt to 63%, while Riverdale’s share climbed 10 ppt to 61%.
Although Staten Island was the only borough where the share of renter-occupied homes expanded, one of the city’s 10 biggest gains in the share of owner-occupied homes happened here: In Manor Heights (#8) — a neighborhood made up entirely of houses — the share of owner-occupied homes rose 11 ppt to 67%. Granted, the neighborhood’s overall number of occupied units barely changed, but the number of rentals fell by about 350 units while owner-occupied homes rose by roughly 400 in a sign that much of the existing stock of occupied units shifted toward owners.
Top 10 Neighborhoods Where Renters Gained Ground
Where Renters Gained the Most Ground: Staten Island Neighborhoods Dominate
Six of the 10 NYC neighborhoods with the sharpest gains were on Staten Island, while three sat along the Queens waterfront in the Howard Beach area and one was in Manhattan. Yet, if Staten Island’s slight overall shift toward renters seemed modest at the borough level, the neighborhood data shows where the most drastic increases in the share of renter-occupied homes were concentrated.
Most of these Staten Island neighborhoods have long been ownership strongholds, and renters still make up a minority in all but two of them — Stapleton and Tudor City. Moreover, the rise in renter-occupied homes doesn’t always come at the expense of owners: In several of these neighborhoods, rentals simply grew faster than the owner-occupied homes.
Stapleton (#1) recorded the sharpest gain citywide: Its share of renter-occupied homes climbed 22 ppt to reach 77% of its occupied housing stock. This came as the number of rentals nearly doubled while the share of owner-occupied homes was almost halved.
Much of the growth in renter-occupied homes coincided with new rental construction on the neighborhood’s waterfront. For example, on the former Homeport naval base, Ironstate’s Urby development brought 571 apartments in its first phase with its first building opening in 2016. As a result, Stapleton became one of the few Staten Island neighborhoods where renters clearly outnumber owners.
On the South Shore, Charleston (#2) posted the second-largest citywide gain of 20 ppt, with its renter-occupied share doubling to 39%. The number of rentals also grew 42%, but the stronger driver was a steep drop in owner-occupied homes, which were nearly halved in the course of a decade.
Along the East Shore, Midland Beach (#3) gained 13 ppt in its renter-occupied share to reach 29% of the neighborhood’s occupied units. This shift came as the neighborhood recovered from Hurricane Sandy, when many damaged homes were auctioned off to be rebuilt. Then, in the following years, the neighborhood’s housing stock grew by nearly two-thirds. Renter-occupied homes nearly tripled to account for much of that growth, while the number of owner-occupied homes rose at a much slower pace.
Richmond Valley came in at #4 in the ranking as the renter-occupied share rose 11 ppt to 32%, even though its number of rentals remained flat. The increase came entirely from a decline in owner-occupied homes, which helped tip the balance significantly in a neighborhood with an overall modest number of occupied units.
Then, at #5, Bulls Head’s number of rentals more than doubled, translating to an 11-ppt increase in the share of renter-occupied homes, which accounted for 32% of the overall stock of occupied units. At the same time, the share of owner-occupied homes in Bulls Head dropped by 11 ppt, going from 80% in 2014 to 68% a decade later.
Dongan Hills (#6) also expanded its share of renter-occupied homes by 10 ppt. As a result, it climbed from 38% to 48%, bringing the neighborhood to a near-even split between renters and owners. Here, the total number of homes barely changed, but owner-occupied homes declined while renter-occupied properties grew, suggesting that owner-occupied homes were turned into rentals.
In Queens, its three entries in the ranking moved at a similar pace: The share of renter-occupied homes rose by 9.7 ppt in Hamilton Beach (#7), 9.4 ppt in Ramblersville (#8) and 9.2 ppt in Old Howard Beach (#9). And, because all three neighborhoods had similar owner- and renter-occupied splits in 2014, all rose to around 30% renter-occupied a decade later.
It’s worth noting here that, in all three of these neighborhoods, the number of owner-occupied homes still increased, but significantly less so than the number of rentals. Moreover, like Staten Island’s East Shore, this stretch of waterfront was heavily damaged by Sandy and required significant rebuilding. In fact, Old Howard Beach was among the neighborhoods with the highest number of homes in the city’s Build It Back program (725).
Lastly, the only Manhattan neighborhood in the top-10 ranking is Tudor City (#10), where the renter-occupied share rose by nine ppt to 67% of the total occupied homes. Here, the number of rentals grew by about one-third to surpass 1,200 units, while owner-occupied homes edged down slightly to a total of just over 600 in 2024.
A Decade of NYC Housing Shifts
Slightly More Room for Owners in a Predominantly Renters’ City
A decade of data shows that NYC homeownership trended up even in places long defined by renting. As such, some Manhattan neighborhoods saw their share of owner-occupied homes increase due to new condos added to the market, in addition to rental conversions. Meanwhile, in some Bronx neighborhoods, the share of owner-occupied homes climbed at a significantly faster pace than the renter-occupied one.
On the other hand, new rental development in Staten Island drove the borough’s share of owner-occupied homes down slightly, making it the one exception to the citywide trend. Of course, the borough remains firmly an ownership stronghold, but the last decade shows its housing market slowly diversifying — a shift that will likely continue as more larger-scale projects like the upcoming NorthShoreNYC emerge.
Despite seeing fewer drastic shifts, Queens added more owner-occupied homes than any other borough between 2014 and 2024, consistently expanding its housing stock and cementing its second place behind Staten Island in terms of elevated shares of homeownership. During the same period, Brooklyn added the most homes in the city, yet its owner-renter balance held steady in a sign that demand from buyers and renters grew in tandem and that new housing broadly reflected the borough’s existing mix.
Overall, for buyers, renters and investors alike, the most meaningful homeownership trends are unfolding at a neighborhood level, shaped by what gets built, what gets converted and how existing homes change hands.
How Every NYC Neighborhood Compares Today
Explore all 282 NYC neighborhoods, ranked from the most owner-occupied to the most renter-occupied, for a complete snapshot of where New Yorkers own and where they rent.
Methodology
The data used in this study was sourced from the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (ACS) 5-Year Estimates for 2024 (table S2501), collected at the census tract level, as well as the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (ACS) 5-Year Estimates for 2014 (table S2501).
The following process was used to break down the data:
- The Census tracts were mapped to NYC neighborhoods using PropertyShark boundaries. 30% of tracts crossed two or more neighborhoods. For tracts spanning multiple neighborhoods, housing units figures were divided proportionally based on how much of the tract’s area fell within each neighborhood.
- Two separate mappings were done, one for each year as the census tracts have changed between 2014 and 2024.
- The figures were summed at the neighborhood level and owner or renter occupancy rates were calculated as a share of the total occupied housing units in each of the two years analyzed. The comparison was done at the neighborhood level.
Banner Image: Rising rentership. Image Credit – Property Shark
