OPINION: Staten Island’s Homelessness Debate Needs Better Measure Of Success
STATEN ISLAND’S HOMELESSNESS DEBATE NEEDS A BETTER MEASURE OF SUCCESS
Why the borough must move beyond shelter beds and build a measurable pathway to permanent housing and independence.
Editor’s note: We’ve previously covered the issue of homelessness on Staten Island. We shared that there are only two functional, operational shelters on the island, with about 200 street homeless individuals in recent surveys. One of the shelters has a 300 person capacity and is only open to women and children, the other is a 100 bed shelter for adult men. Project Hospitality doesn’t have overnight beds itself, though it functions as a hub to connect people in need to the services they qualify for. So a person can go there for hot lunch, groceries for dinner for the week, HEAP and SNAP applications, child welfare needs, and other public and private assistance programs they may qualify for. Homeless persons can be connected with services from there, though there are limitations on what’s available. There are also social workers at multiple organizations to assist people whose children were placed in foster care to reenter the workforce, get stable housing, and reunite with their children, which in many instances is to the benefit of the child. Salvation Army is another charity hub that connects people with services and also meets them where they are with their sit down meal program.
The debate over homelessness on Staten Island has increasingly focused on where New York City should establish its next shelter. From Port Richmond to Clifton and Charleston, residents and elected officials have raised concerns about proposed facilities, while the city maintains its responsibility to provide emergency accommodation for people with nowhere else to turn.
But an equally important question deserves attention: What happens after someone enters the shelter system, and what is being done to help them move into permanent housing?
The proposed 200-bed family shelter at the former Bayley Seton Hospital campus brings this issue into focus. Council Member Kamillah Hanks has argued that the North Shore has already accommodated several shelter and temporary housing facilities and that the site should instead be considered for permanent affordable housing. Her proposal deserves serious examination alongside the city’s responsibility to provide emergency shelter.
Neither residents’ concerns nor the needs of homeless families should be dismissed. However, debating shelter locations without a broader housing strategy risks addressing immediate needs without resolving the circumstances that keep people homeless.
The numbers also require careful interpretation. New York City’s 2026 Homeless Outreach Population Estimate identified 10 unsheltered individuals on Staten Island, down from 39 in 2025. These figures represent a one-night estimate of people living outdoors, not the total number experiencing homelessness or those staying in temporary accommodation.
Staten Island already has organisations providing important support. Project Hospitality delivers street outreach, emergency assistance, housing placement, medical and psychiatric care coordination, addiction recovery services and employment support. Its 24-hour drop-in centre, alongside outpatient and residential addiction recovery programmes, demonstrates that much of the foundation for a stronger response already exists.
Homelessness does not have one explanation. Some people need addiction treatment or mental healthcare, while families may simply need affordable housing, employment opportunities or assistance navigating an increasingly expensive housing market. Treating everyone experiencing homelessness as someone struggling with addiction would be both inaccurate and unfair.
The opportunity is to connect these services through a coordinated, accountable programme.
A pathway from homelessness to independence
New York City, working with nonprofit organisations, healthcare providers, educational institutions and local employers, should establish a Staten Island Pathway to Independence initiative.
Three practical measures could make a difference.
First, every participant should receive an individual assessment and a designated case manager to coordinate housing assistance, healthcare, mental health support, addiction treatment where appropriate, benefits and employment services. People should not have to navigate disconnected organisations without anyone taking responsibility for helping them progress.
Second, employment should become a stronger part of the strategy. Local businesses, construction companies and vocational institutions could participate in a voluntary second chance employment partnership offering skills training, apprenticeships, interview preparation and legitimate job opportunities.
For people recovering from addiction, meaningful employment can restore structure and purpose. For families facing housing insecurity, a stable income can help prevent homelessness.
Third, permanent housing must remain the ultimate objective. Temporary accommodation should be a bridge towards stability, not an indefinite arrangement. Eligible individuals and families should receive assistance accessing rental subsidies, affordable housing and supportive accommodation suited to their circumstances.
Public investment must produce results
The city is already committing significant public resources to homelessness services. A June 2026 City Record contract notice lists a $5.19 million FY2027 renewal for Staten Island outreach services involving Project Hospitality.
That investment makes transparency essential.
The city should publish quarterly performance reports showing how many people are reached through outreach, accept shelter placements, enter voluntary treatment, secure permanent housing and maintain stable accommodation after six and twelve months. Employment outcomes, programme completion, waiting times and expenditure should also be included.
Taxpayers and residents deserve to know whether public investment is producing lasting improvements, rather than simply increasing the number of available beds.
Communities also deserve a neighbourhood impact agreement before major shelter developments proceed. Clear information about staffing, security, sanitation, healthcare access, transportation and available services should be provided, supported by regular public meetings and a community advisory structure.
Meanwhile, the former Bayley Seton Hospital campus deserves an independent feasibility assessment comparing the proposed shelter with the potential for permanent affordable and supportive housing, including the infrastructure and financing each option would require.
This should be an evidence-based decision, not a political contest between competing neighbourhood interests.
A better definition of success
Staten Island has an opportunity to demonstrate that homelessness policy can be compassionate while remaining accountable.
Emergency shelter is necessary, but it cannot be the final measure of success. The real objective should be helping people secure safe homes, access appropriate healthcare, find employment where possible and regain control of their lives.
People experiencing homelessness deserve more than temporary accommodation. Residents deserve responsible planning, and taxpayers deserve evidence that their money is making a lasting difference.
The question should no longer be simply how many shelter beds New York City can provide. It should be how many people it can help move beyond needing them.
A shelter should be a doorway to a better future, not the final destination.
Tony Mark Ramjewan
Banner Image: Homeless person. Image Credit – Brigitte Werner
![Staten Island's [Hyper]Local Paper(less). Staten Island News.](https://statenislander.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Staten-Island-News-Masthead-Full-Size-Wider-2025.png)




There are no comments yet
Why not be the first