Brooklyn Firefighter Filmed By Journalist On 9/11: Still Looking For Him 25 Years Later

Share

Editor’s note: Below is a video of about five minutes of footage from September 11th and September 12th, filmed by Nina Vishneva.  Pictured in the video, as well as below the article, is the firefighter she still hasn’t been able to identify all these years later:

 

I’m Still Looking for This Firefighter
By Nina Vishneva
I’m still looking for this firefighter. He was filmed on the morning of September 11, 2001. His helmet says “Engine 205.” I don’t know his name. I don’t know whether he survived that day. I don’t know whether he later became one of the many firefighters whose lives were cut short by 9/11-related illnesses.For twenty-five years, I’ve wondered who he was.I was one of the journalists with NTV International covering the attacks in New York. Our studio was two blocks from the World Trade Center. My colleagues and I filmed almost continuously for days and weeks after the attacks.We filmed firefighters, rescue workers, survivors and families. We filmed the ruins and the search for survivors.In 2002, our reporting on September 11 was recognized by The National Academy of Television Arts & Sciences.But what stayed with me was not the television footage. It was the people.I remember the first hours.I remember the people trying to understand what was happening while it was happening. I remember the fear, the confusion and the desperate hope that somehow, someone might still be alive.But most of all, I remember the firefighters and other first responders. At Ground Zero, people were still hoping to find someone alive. Rescue workers worked around the clock. Firefighters, police officers, construction workers, volunteers and civilians worked together. One firefighter told me that everybody supported everybody else. They called one another brothers. People came from across America, Canada and Europe.The streets were covered in gray dust. Fires were still burning underneath the ruins. Smoke hung over Lower Manhattan.

Women’s shoes were lying everywhere. People had kicked them off while running.

For weeks, the rescue workers worked in that dust. At the time, nobody knew exactly what those weeks would cost them.

I interviewed retired firefighter Robert Serra. He had graduated from the fire academy only one day before September 11. That day was supposed to be his day off.

He was driving to hockey practice when he saw the North Tower burning. He went home, put on the brand-new turnout gear he had received the day before, and went to the World Trade Center. He told me, laughing, that he was still pulling the tags off his gear on the way there because it had never been used.

Years later, I asked him what he remembered most.

“The smell,” he said.

I remember Eric Robertson, a firefighter from California who drove across the country with his search-and-rescue dog, Porkchop. All commercial flights had been grounded, so they drove. Eric spent weeks at Ground Zero searching through the gray dust. When human remains were found, he marked the location. Years later, he developed multiple cancers and serious lung disease. But when he talked to me, he didn’t talk about himself first. He talked about the people they were trying to bring home.

There were many people they could not bring home.

Lenny Ragaglia was one of them.

Lenny was with Engine 54. He wasn’t supposed to be working on September 11. He had planned to have the day off, but the night before, another firefighter asked him to switch shifts.That decision changed everything.His sister showed me the last photograph ever taken of him. He was sitting in the fire truck on the way to the World Trade Center. If you enlarge the picture, you can see his hand through the window. His family knew that was where Lenny always sat. His remains were never found. Today, both of his sons are FDNY firefighters.I have never forgotten that photograph.I also interviewed the wife and daughters of Thomas Alioto of Ladder 147. Thomas survived the collapse of the North Tower. He spent months at Ground Zero searching for friends. There is a famous photograph of him kneeling in the ruins. It was published around the world.But surviving September 11 did not mean leaving September 11 behind. Toxic exposure damaged his lungs. He died in 2019. His daughters turned their family home into a memorial. One of them told me she could still smell the smoke on his helmet.I interviewed retired FDNY paramedic Gary Smiley, too.He survived both tower collapses. At one point, he was thrown underneath an ambulance. He survived and went back to searching for friends who were trapped. Later, he dedicated his life to helping families of first responders who became sick because of September 11.But for many first responders, September 11 did not end when the towers came down.The Fire Department lost 343 members that day. Then firefighters began dying from cancer and other illnesses.For many families, there was never a funeral in the usual sense. There was no body. Nothing to bury.I saw what that meant for people.

And that is how I came to another September 11 story – on Staten Island.

Before the attacks, Wendy Pellegrino lived across from a small, abandoned piece of land. She told me that there was nothing there. “Here was nothing. It was just dirt.”

On September 11, Wendy learned that her husband, who worked in one of the World Trade Center towers, was there. He managed to escape. That night, Wendy went outside. She put a candle on the empty piece of land for the people who had died. She put up American flags and a sign:

“God Bless Our Heroes.”


The next day, someone brought the first photograph. Then another photograph appeared. Then another. People began calling Wendy because everyone in the neighborhood knew she lived there. They asked her to turn photographs of their loved ones toward the street so they could see their faces as they drove by. Wendy began to understand what they needed. Their relatives were gone. In many cases, their remains had not been recovered. But they needed somewhere to see them. The little piece of land gradually became a memorial.

Wendy calls it Angels’ Circle.

She eventually decided that the memorial would be for people whose remains had never been found. She calls them angels. For many families, it became the place where they could come to remember someone they could never bury. There are photographs everywhere. There are candles and flowers. Over the years, the memorial has develo

ped its own traditions. Wendy is the official caretaker. Volunteers help her maintain the little park. Neighbors come. Girl Scouts come. They plant flowers, arrange seasonal bouquets and replace candles.Christian DiMeo, a retired military man, became one of Wendy’s main helpers. He told me that this place needs to be preserved because young people need to know what happened.“These are people who simply went to work that day and never came home,” he said.Retired firefighter Mark Anrein also comes to Angels’ Circle. He knew many of the firefighters whose photographs are displayed there. On September 11, Mark was off duty. He was watching the news when the second plane hit. Then a message appeared on television telling firefighters who were off duty to report to the World Trade Center.He went.Among the photographs at Angels’ Circle is Lenny Ragaglia’s.Mark told me that many of the people who come to the memorial never found the remains of their loved ones.“For many of them, this is the only place they can come,” he said. “For them, time stopped here.”There is another story at the memorial that I remember.Martin Higgins, another local volunteer, noticed a photograph of one of the search-and-rescue dogs. There was also a small statue. He told me he didn’t know exactly why, but the photograph and the statue affected him so much that he sat down and started crying. What upset him even more was where the little memorial had been placed – next to a garbage can. So Martin put a miniature fire hydrant beside it.His explanation was very simple.“When people leave, they’ll notice it,” he said. “And they’ll smile. And I did that.”

Over the years, I kept coming back to the same stories.

To Lenny’s family, who never got his remains.

To the firefighters who survived September 11 and then spent years fighting illnesses caused by what they breathed at Ground Zero. To the families who created their own memorials because there was nowhere else to go. I remember what one firefighter told me about those first months. The first six months after September 11 felt like one long week. They couldn’t tell the days from the nights anymore. They only came back to reality when they went to funerals. And the funerals didn’t stop.

That is probably why I still think about this firefighter from Engine 205. He is there for only a moment in our footage. He looks directly into the camera, and then he disappears back into the smoke. Twenty-five years later, I still don’t know who he was.

Maybe someone reading this will recognize him. Maybe someone from Engine 205 will remember him.

I would really like to put a name to the face I’ve remembered for twenty-five years.

 

September 11th firefighters. Image Credit – Nina Vishneva

September 11th firefighters. Image Credit – Nina Vishneva

September 11th firefighters. Image Credit – Nina Vishneva

September 11th firefighters. Image Credit – Nina Vishneva

September 11th firefighters. Image Credit – Nina Vishneva

September 11th firefighters. Image Credit – Nina Vishneva

 

Banner Image: Unknown firefighter on 9/11. Image Credit – Nina Vishneva


Share

There are no comments yet

Why not be the first

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

code